Mental Incapacity in Contracts – Section 12 of ICA, 1872

The concept of mental incapacity plays a pivotal role in determining the validity of contracts under the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (ICA). Section 12 of the ICA specifies that a person is capable of contracting only if they can understand the terms and implications of the agreement. Mental incapacity, including temporary conditions like intoxication, can vitiate this capacity under certain conditions.

UNSOUNDNESS DUE TO ALCOHOL

CHACKO V. MAHADEVAN

    (Inadequate consideration though not invalid can be a ground to see whether consent was freely given- Sc.25)

    • P sold one cent of land to D for Rs.18,000 and another for Rs.1000 each.
    • P filed a suit to set aside the transaction alleging that he was given alcohol by D and it was under its influence that the document was signed.
    • Medical certificate showing that P was not of sound mind (MENTAL INCAPACITY) at the time of signing.
    • Res ipsa loquitor- One cent for 18,000 and then one for Rs.1000.
    • Sale deed quashed.

    SELF-INDUCED ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION

    S BASAVARAJ V. V.N ADILAKSHMAMMA

    • D borrowed money from P and refused to reply on the ground that he was of unsound mind while entering into the contract.
    • The medical certificate was generic in nature and failed to address the mental capacity at the time of making the contract.
    • The court would be extremely cautious when a person brings himself in a position of alcohol addiction and then claims to be of unsound mind.
    • Even those suffering from long term addiction would have lucid breaks where they can enter into contracts.
    • AVOIDANCE OF CONTRACT IS NOT ONLY EXCEPTIONAL BUT GRANTED ONLY IN THE RAREST OF RARE CASES.
    • Lack of conclusive proof; Appeal fails.

      COMMON LAW POSITION ON MENTAL INCAPACITY

      THE IMPERIAL LOAN COMPANY LTD. V. STONE –

      • D signed a promissory note and it was later claimed that he was of unsound mind while executing it. D claimed that P knew of it when entering into the contract.
      • Insanity will lead to a contract becoming void when
      • The person was of unsound mind when entering into the contract.
      • This was known to the plaintiff while entering into the contract (Not applicable in India).

        MENTAL INCAPACITY

        CHARANJITH SINGH V. CHATTRANJA.N PAL

        • Plaintiff was alleged to be of unsound mind and filed a suit(through his brother) claiming possession of property which had been transferred via a sale deed.
        • D claimed that the deed was signed in the presence of P’s father and was valid.
        • Conclusive medical certificate of incapacity produced. Once the party establishes mental incapacity, then onus shifts to the other to prove that he was mentally sound while entering the contract.
        • The presence of father does not validate a contract otherwise invalid of mental incapacity.

          NILIMA GHOSE CASE

          1. Appellant could not prove that she was of unsound mind at the time of entertain into the contract.
          2. U/s 12 of ICA, unsoundness of mind would vitiate the capacity of a party to enter into a contract only if the party was of unsound mind, (i.e., incapable of forming a rational judgment as to the effects of the contract upon himself/herself) AT THE TIME OF THE MAKING OF THE CONTRACT – proving general unsoundness is insufficient.

          Conclusion

          Courts examine claims of mental incapacity with strict scrutiny. While contracts can be voided for incapacity, the burden of proof lies heavily on the claimant to establish incapacity at the time of agreement. This legal stance safeguards fairness in commercial dealings while preventing misuse of such defenses.


          Read – Hussainara Khatoon & Ors. v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar

          Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

          Get Daily Updates

          Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

          Get Daily Updates

          Leave a Reply

          Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

          Next Article

          Paid Internship at Adab Singh Kapoor & Associates

          Adab Singh Kapoor & Associates, a renowned law firm based in New Delhi, is inviting applications for a paid full-time internship focusing on Matrimonial Law and Criminal Law. This is an excellent opportunity for law students to gain hands-on experience and engage with real-world legal cases. By working at this established firm, interns will get exposure to two highly significant fields of law.

          Internship Focus: Matrimonial & Criminal Law

          Interns will have the opportunity to immerse themselves in Matrimonial Law, dealing with legal aspects of marriage, divorce, alimony, and child custody, as well as Criminal Law, where they will work on criminal cases, assisting in legal research, and preparing case files. The internship allows students to sharpen their research and analytical skills, as well as their ability to work on active cases under the supervision of experienced attorneys. Interns will gain practical insights into how law is practiced and applied in matrimonial disputes and criminal cases.

          Eligibility Criteria

          To qualify for this internship, applicants must meet the following requirements:

          • Strong command of English, both spoken and written
          • Excellent communication and interpersonal skills
          • Prior writing experience in legal journals or blogs
          • A demonstrated interest or previous internship experience in Matrimonial Law or Criminal Law

          Who Can Apply at Adab Singh Kapoor & Associates ?

          • 3rd, 4th, and 5th-year students of a 5-year law program
          • 2nd and 3rd-year students of a 3-year law program

          Vacancies & Application Process

          There are 2 to 3 internship positions available each month. To apply, send your CV via email to [email protected] or check the official job page for more details. This internship is a great stepping stone for students looking to build their careers in Matrimonial Law and Criminal Law, offering a valuable opportunity to work with seasoned legal professionals.

          Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

          Get Daily Updates

          Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

          Get Daily Updates

          Next Article

          Contact Us

          For Submitting a Post

          For Banner ads & admission campaigns

          Timing

          Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)

          See the below animation to allow notifications.

          Start getting Lawdrishti updates useful for you!

          Contact Us

          For Submitting a Post

          For Banner ads & admission campaigns

          Contact us
          For Submitting a Post
          For Banner ads & admission campaigns
          Timing

          Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)