Article 265: A Basis for Legitimate Tax Imposition

Introduction: The Concept of Grundnorm

All human-made laws derive their legitimacy from a fundamental law, often referred to as the “parent law.” In legal terminology, this concept was introduced by Hans Kelsen in his ‘Pure Theory of Law.’ He coined the term “Grundnorm” to describe the fundamental law from which all other laws gain their authority. In India, the Constitution can be considered the perfect example of a Grundnorm.

Article 265: Taxes and the Authority of Law

The Constitution of India comprises 448 articles, one of which is Article 265, titled “Taxes not to be imposed save by authority of law.” The bare provision reads:

“No tax shall be levied or collected except by the authority of law.”

This clause contains two essential elements:

  1. A taxing statute must exist.
  2. The statute must be passed by an appropriate authority to ensure its validity.

This protects citizens from exploitation under the guise of authority.

The Definition of “Authority” in Article 265

The term “authority” has a broad scope. In India, the Parliament holds the supreme power to make laws, provided the subject matter falls within the Union’s legislative domain. Specifically, in taxation, Parliament can only impose taxes on subjects listed under the Union List. However, Parliament can sometimes impose taxes on subjects in the State or Concurrent Lists.

States also have the authority to impose taxes, as long as they pertain to matters within the State List. Similarly, municipalities, local bodies, and other government institutions can impose taxes if a law allows it.

Role of Judiciary in Interpreting Authority

The judiciary has the power to interpret and validate the authority of institutions claiming to impose taxes. Several key cases highlight how the courts have examined this issue.

Case Law: Poona Municipality vs. Dattatraya Nagesh Deodhar [AIR 1965 SC 555]

This case dealt with the recovery of money related to octroi duty, a local tax collected on goods brought into a city. Poona City Municipality had been collecting octroi duty since 1901. After the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949 came into effect, the municipality deducted 10% from octroi duty refunds, despite the new Act not authorizing such a deduction.

Key Rulings:

  • The deduction was not permitted under the Bombay Municipal Corporation’s powers.
  • No standing order justified the deduction.
  • The deduction had no legal basis after the enactment of the new law.

Case Law: Chhotabhai Jethabhai Patel vs. Union of India [AIR 1962 SC 1006]

In this case, a tobacco company challenged the retroactive imposition of excise duty under the Finance Act, 1951. The Parliament had passed a bill amending the Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944, and applied the increased duty retroactively.

Key Rulings:

  • Parliament, as a sovereign body, can pass laws with both prospective and retrospective effects.
  • The duties levied under the Central Excises and Salt Act were valid, even when applied retrospectively.

Conclusion

The Constitution of India, as the Grundnorm, governs all laws, including taxing statutes. It ensures that taxation laws do not infringe upon the rights of taxpayers. The judiciary plays a critical role in interpreting the provisions of the Constitution, including determining which authorities are empowered to impose taxes and under what conditions.

Download Law Notes here.

Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Article

Legal Associate Job at ideaForge – Apply Now!

About ideaForge

Are you looking for an exciting Legal Associate job at ideaForge? ideaForge is a leader in the Indian unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) market and has the largest deployment of indigenous drones in the country. With one of its drones taking off every five minutes for surveillance or mapping, the company is at the forefront of drone technology. To continue this growth, ideaForge is now hiring a Legal Associate to help manage its legal functions and ensure full compliance with regulations.


Job Overview

As a Legal Associate at ideaForge, you will be responsible for handling a wide range of legal matters. Not only will you review contracts and offer legal counsel, but you will also ensure that the company complies with all applicable laws. Furthermore, you will collaborate with different departments to protect the company’s legal interests. This position is ideal for professionals experienced in corporate law, contract management, and regulatory frameworks, especially in the technology or aerospace industry.


Eligibility Requirements

To be considered for this Legal Associate job at ideaForge, you must meet the following criteria:

  • A law degree (LLB/LLM) from a recognized institution.
  • At least 2 years of legal experience in a similar role.
  • Strong understanding of contract law, corporate law, and compliance regulations.
  • Excellent research, communication, and negotiation skills.
  • The ability to work both independently and collaboratively in a fast-paced environment.
  • Prior experience in the technology or aerospace sectors is a plus.
  • Proficiency in legal research tools and MS Office applications.

Key Responsibilities

1. Contract Review and Management

  • Review, draft, and manage various legal documents, including agreements, contracts, and legal correspondence.
  • Ensure all contracts comply with relevant laws, regulations, and company policies.
  • Additionally, collaborate with internal teams to identify any contractual risks and mitigate them.
  • Conduct thorough legal research on topics like intellectual property, drone manufacturing laws, and regulatory compliance.
  • Stay up-to-date with changes in laws and regulations that impact the drone industry. Moreover, provide proactive legal advice to the internal teams.
  • Provide legal support to various departments, such as Sales, Operations, and R&D.
  • Draft and review internal policies, memoranda, and legal opinions. Additionally, maintain accurate legal records and documentation.

How to Apply

If you are interested in this Legal Associate job at ideaForge and have 2-3 years of experience in corporate law, submit your application to legal@ideaforgetech.com. Don’t miss this opportunity to work with India’s leading drone manufacturer!


Explore More Job Opportunities

Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Next Article

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

contact@lawdrishti.com

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

advertise@lawdrishti.com

Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)

See the below animation to allow notifications.

Start getting Lawdrishti updates useful for you!

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

Contact us
For Submitting a Post
For Banner ads & admission campaigns
Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)