Not mandatory for minors to repudiate voidable transaction executed by guardian

In K.S. Shivappa vs Smt. K. Neelamma decided on 7 October 2025, the Supreme Court restored the Trial Court’s decree holding that it is not mandatory for a minor to file a suit to repudiate a voidable transaction executed by a guardian; conduct suffices. The Supreme Court considered whether a minor must always file a suit on attaining majority to repudiate a voidable transaction executed by a guardian or whether repudiation could occur through conduct.

Rudrappa, the father and guardian of three minor sons, purchased two plots in 1971. Without court permission, he sold Plot No. 56 to S.I. Bidari (later transferred to B.T. Jayadevamma) and Plot No. 57 to Krishnoji Rao (later transferred to K. Neelamma). After attaining majority, the surviving minors, with their mother, sold both plots to K.S. Shivappa. Jayadevamma’s suit over Plot 56 was dismissed by the High Court, holding the minors’ sale effectively repudiated their father’s earlier deed. For Plot 57, the Trial Court favored Shivappa, but the High Court reversed, ruling Neelamma had valid title since no suit had been filed to challenge the original sale. Shivappa then appealed to the Supreme Court.

Section 8(2) and (3) of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act make it clear that any transfer of a minor’s property by a guardian without court permission is voidable at the instance of the minor. Legal texts (Travellyan, Mulla) and case law (Abdul Rahman v. Sukhdayal Singh, G. Annamalai Pillai v. District Revenue Officer, Chacko Mathew v. Ayyappan Kutty) confirm that such voidable transactions can be repudiated either by filing a suit or through unequivocal conduct, such as selling the property after attaining majority.

In the present case, the minors had repudiated the sale of Plot No. 57 by transferring it to Shivappa after attaining majority. Neelamma had failed to prove her title or verify that Krishnoji Rao had valid ownership. Her Power-of-Attorney witness could not fill this evidentiary gap. Therefore, Shivappa had valid rights over Plot No. 57. A bench of Justices Pankaj Mithal and Prasanna B. Varale allowed the appeal.

Takeaway: A minor can repudiate a sale made by their guardian without court permission upon attaining majority, either by acting on the property (like selling it) or filing a suit. If no challenge is made, subsequent purchasers relying on the original sale may acquire valid title. Essentially, action or inaction by the minor determines whether a voidable transaction is upheld or canceled.

Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Article

Sources of Law and Their Importance

Understanding the Main Sources of Law in Simple Words

In our last post on the different types of law, we looked at criminal law, civil law, constitutional law, and more. You can read it here: Different Types of Law Explained Simply.

Now we will understand where laws actually come from. These starting points are called the sources of law. They decide what rules exist, how they are made, and how they can change over time.

What Do We Mean by “Sources of Law”?

A source of law is basically the origin or starting point from where laws come. Just like water flows from a river’s source, legal rules flow from certain recognised authorities or traditions. In India, there is not just one source of law. Our legal system is a mix of written rules, court decisions, customs, and even international agreements. Knowing the sources of law helps us see why laws have authority and why people are expected to follow them.

The Constitution

The Constitution of India is the supreme source of law. It is like the master rulebook for the country. It sets out the structure of the government, lists the powers of different authorities, and guarantees fundamental rights to citizens. Every law in India must follow the Constitution. If any law goes against it, courts can declare that law invalid. This power is called judicial review. For example, in 2017, the Supreme Court struck down a part of a law that restricted privacy rights, saying it violated the Constitution. This shows how the Constitution sits at the top of the legal ladder.

Legislation (Statutory Law)

Legislation means laws made by elected bodies like Parliament or State Legislatures. These laws are written down and officially passed, so they are easy to find and follow. Legislation is important because it can quickly address new issues. For instance, when cybercrime became common, Parliament passed the Information Technology Act to handle offences like hacking, identity theft, and online fraud. In India, law-making power is divided between the central government and state governments, based on the Union List, State List, and Concurrent List in the Constitution.

Judicial Decisions (Case Law)

Courts not only apply laws but also interpret them. Sometimes, when a law is unclear, the court’s interpretation becomes a standard for future cases. This is called precedent. For example, if the Supreme Court explains the meaning of a constitutional right, that interpretation will guide all lower courts in similar cases. This system makes laws more predictable and consistent. A famous example is the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973), where the Supreme Court ruled that the “basic structure” of the Constitution cannot be changed by Parliament. This principle is still followed today.

Customs and Traditions

Before modern law-making started, many rules came from customs — practices that communities followed for generations. Even today, some customs are recognised as valid law if they meet certain conditions like being reasonable, certain, and accepted for a long time. For example, certain community-specific marriage ceremonies are legally valid because they are established customs. However, harmful customs like child marriage have been made illegal.

Religious Laws

In personal matters like marriage, divorce, adoption, and inheritance, religious laws play an important role. India has a system of personal laws for different religious communities. For example, Hindus follow the Hindu Marriage Act and Hindu Succession Act. Muslims follow Shariat law for certain matters. Christians have their own marriage and divorce laws. These laws are partly based on religious texts and partly on statutory law passed by Parliament.

Delegated Legislation

Sometimes Parliament or State Legislatures give power to a government authority to make detailed rules under a law. This is called delegated legislation. For example, the Motor Vehicles Act gives the Transport Ministry power to decide speed limits, vehicle safety standards, and driving licence rules. This saves time and allows experts to handle technical details without going through the whole law-making process again.

International Treaties and Conventions

International law can also influence Indian law. When India signs a treaty or agreement with other countries, it may need to make or change laws to follow the agreement. For example, after joining the World Trade Organization (WTO), India updated its intellectual property laws to meet global standards. Similarly, environmental agreements like the Paris Climate Accord have shaped India’s policies on pollution control and renewable energy.

Why These Sources Matter

Understanding the sources of law is important for several reasons. First, it gives clarity about authority. We know which rules have the highest authority, like the Constitution. Second, it explains the law-making process. We understand how new laws are made and old ones are changed. Third, it helps in legal research because lawyers and students can easily find the relevant law if they know its source. Fourth, it improves public awareness so that citizens can better understand their rights and duties. If we know the source, we also know its limits. For example, a custom may be valid unless it conflicts with a written law.

The Connection Between Sources

These sources do not work in isolation. They are connected. The Constitution allows Parliament to make laws. Parliament’s laws are interpreted by the judiciary. Judicial decisions sometimes refer to customs. International treaties may inspire new legislation. This network of sources keeps the legal system flexible yet stable.

Everyday Examples

Let’s look at a few everyday examples that show how different sources of law interact. Driving rules are made under legislation like the Motor Vehicles Act, with detailed delegated rules by the Transport Ministry. Marriage registration is governed by personal religious laws and supported by state legislation for registration. Pollution control is influenced by international agreements and enforced through national legislation like the Environment Protection Act. Property disputes are resolved by courts applying statutes and sometimes recognising valid customs.

Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Next Article

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

contact@lawdrishti.com

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

advertise@lawdrishti.com

Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)

See the below animation to allow notifications.

Start getting Lawdrishti updates useful for you!

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

Contact us
For Submitting a Post
For Banner ads & admission campaigns
Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)