Rental or mesne profits arise only upon unlawful occupation: SC


Justices Augustine George Masih and C.R. Gavai on a judgement dated 15 October 2025, Nashik Municipal Corporation v. Landowner partly allowed the appeal challenging the High Court’s decision reducing compensation for land acquisition under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 reiterating that rental or mesne profits arise only upon unlawful occupation.

The dispute concerned 37 Ares of land in Nashik that had been reserved for public purposes under the MRTP Act, 1966, and partially acquired decades earlier. The remaining land was used by the Corporation without formal acquisition. After multiple rounds of litigation, the land was finally acquired in 2017, with the SLAO awarding ₹8.69 crore compensation, later enhanced by the Reference Court to ₹20.20 crore along with ₹238 crore as “rental compensation.” The High Court quashed the enhancement, restoring the SLAO’s award.

Before the Supreme Court, the appellant contended that the High Court erred in rejecting the comparable sale deeds relied on by the Reference Court and that the denial of rental compensation was unjust. The Court agreed partly, holding that under Section 26 of the 2013 Act, the Collector must determine market value based on average sale prices of similar lands and not on ready-reckoner rates. It found the Reference Court’s reliance on six sale instances sound and restored the higher compensation of ₹20.20 crore with 9% interest.

However, the claim of rental compensation was rejected. The Court observed that no evidence showed unlawful possession by the Corporation before the appellant’s purchase in 2011, and the original owner retained control over the property. Relying on R.L. Jain v. DDA (2004) 4 SCC 79, it held that rental or mesne profits arise only upon unlawful occupation. Nevertheless, invoking equitable jurisdiction under Section 28 (“seventhly”), the Court directed the Corporation to pay 8% interest on the purchase amount of ₹1.17 crore for the period between the sale deed and the award.

Accordingly, the appeal was partly allowed. The enhanced compensation was restored, but rental compensation was disallowed. The adverse observations and cost of ₹10 lakh imposed by the High Court were set aside.

Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Article

Litigation Associate Job Mumbai | Lex Arjava LLP – Apply Now

Lex Arjava LLP, a full-service law firm expanding its Mumbai office, is inviting applications for Associates and Senior Associates in Litigation. This Litigation Associate job Mumbai provides an excellent opportunity for lawyers at different stages of their careers to gain hands-on exposure to civil, commercial, arbitration, criminal, and corporate dispute matters across multiple forums.

The firm is known for its strategic litigation, arbitration support, and corporate dispute resolution services, making it an ideal workplace for lawyers seeking challenging and dynamic legal work.


About Lex Arjava LLP

Lex Arjava LLP is a pan-India law firm handling a wide range of litigation, arbitration, and corporate dispute matters. The Mumbai office focuses on Civil, Commercial, Arbitration, Criminal, and Real Estate disputes, assisting clients in both advisory and litigation capacities.

Key highlights of the firm:

  • Diverse Litigation Practice: From Section 138 and cheque bounce cases to arbitration, civil recovery, and criminal complaints.
  • Client-Focused Approach: Provides strategic and practical solutions to complex legal issues.
  • Growth Opportunities: Mentorship and career growth opportunities across litigation and corporate dispute resolution.

Working at Lex Arjava LLP allows associates to gain comprehensive exposure to litigation strategy, case handling, and client advisory under the guidance of experienced legal professionals.


Location & Work Mode

  • Location: Mumbai
  • Mode: On-site, full-time

Mumbai provides a vibrant legal environment with access to high-profile commercial and civil matters, tribunals, and appellate courts, making it a hub for litigation practice.


Positions & Vacancies

1. Associate – Litigation

  • PQE: 0–2 years
  • Scope: Section 138, Execution Petitions, Arbitrations, Commercial Suits, Civil Recoveries, Summary Suits, Criminal Complaints, Tribunals, and procedural formalities
  • Role: Litigation support, case handling, and legal analysis

2. Senior Associate – Litigation

  • PQE: Minimum 5 years
  • Scope: Arbitration, Consumer Cases, Cheque Bounce Cases, Writs, Civil Recovery Matters, Summary Suits, Real Estate, and Criminal Matters
  • Role: Leading litigation strategy, execution, and client advisory

This Litigation Associate job Mumbai is suitable for lawyers at junior and mid-senior levels, offering exposure to varied litigation matters and client advisory responsibilities.


Eligibility Criteria

Candidates must meet the following requirements:

  • Qualification: LL.B. (3-year or 5-year program)
  • PQE: As per the role (0–2 years for Associates, 5+ years for Senior Associates)
  • Strong research, drafting, and advocacy skills
  • Ability to handle multiple matters simultaneously and meet deadlines
  • Proactive, client-focused, and adaptable to fast-paced litigation environments

Key Responsibilities

For Associates (0–2 years PQE)

  • Assist in drafting and reviewing pleadings, notices, and applications
  • Support senior lawyers in case strategy, research, and litigation preparation
  • Attend court hearings and tribunals under supervision
  • Conduct legal analysis and provide recommendations on cases

For Senior Associates (5+ years PQE)

  • Lead litigation strategy and execution for client matters
  • Handle arbitration, civil recovery, summary suits, and real estate disputes independently
  • Provide client advisory and representation in courts and tribunals
  • Mentor junior associates and coordinate with team members on complex cases

This role provides practical exposure to diverse legal matters, helping associates build a strong litigation portfolio.


Skills & Qualities Required

  • Strong legal research, drafting, and analytical capabilities
  • Confidence in court appearances and client representation
  • Ability to manage multiple matters and meet tight deadlines
  • Knowledge of civil procedure, commercial laws, arbitration, and criminal procedures
  • Collaborative team player with good communication and interpersonal skills

Why Join Lex Arjava LLP?

  • Exposure to civil, commercial, arbitration, and criminal litigation
  • Hands-on experience with high-value and complex cases
  • Opportunity to learn from senior litigation experts
  • Career growth and mentorship opportunities within a dynamic law firm
  • Build a strong foundation in Indian litigation and dispute resolution practice

For lawyers looking to advance their litigation careers, this Litigation Associate job in Mumbai offers diverse exposure, professional development, and challenging work assignments.


How to Apply

Interested candidates should send their CV to:

Email: hemant.singh@lexarjava.com

Email Subject Line: “Application for Associate (PQE yy/mm)”

Include details such as:

  • Current Firm
  • Designation
  • Years of experience (legal field)
  • Notice period
  • Expected CTC

Applications with complete details are preferred and will be reviewed on a rolling basis.


Conclusion

The Litigation Associate job Mumbai at Lex Arjava LLP is an excellent opportunity for advocates seeking exposure to civil, commercial, arbitration, and criminal matters across multiple courts and tribunals. With roles for both junior and senior associates, the firm offers mentorship, client-facing experience, and a dynamic litigation environment, making it ideal for lawyers aiming to grow in litigation practice in Mumbai.

Apply today to join Lex Arjava LLP and take your litigation career to the next level.


Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Next Article

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

contact@lawdrishti.com

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

advertise@lawdrishti.com

Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)

See the below animation to allow notifications.

Start getting Lawdrishti updates useful for you!

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

Contact us
For Submitting a Post
For Banner ads & admission campaigns
Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)