Isolated similarity does not attract trademark infringement: Pernod Ricard India Private Limited vs Karanveer Singh Chhabra

The Apex Court has held in a recent judgement dated 14 August 2025 that isolated similarity does not attract trademark infringement. In Pernod Ricard India Private Limited vs Karanveer Singh Chhabra, a bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan dismissed the appeal and did not interfere with the findings of the Commercial Court and the High Court. The request for an interim injunction order was rejected because the appellants failed to establish grounds for deceptive similarity leading to trademark violation.

The plaintiffs are Pernod Ricard India Pvt. Ltd., manufacturers of well-known whisky brands ‘BLENDERS PRIDE’, since 1995 and ‘IMPERIAL BLUE’ since 1997, the turnover of both amounting to ₹4,400 Cr. Both marks are registered. The defendant was London Pride Distillers Ltd., selling whisky under the mark ‘LONDON PRIDE’. There were allegations of trademark infringement and passing off due to deceptive similarity. 

The bench referred to the Anti-Dissection Rule from a prior decision in Kaviraj Pandit Durga Dutt Sharma v. Navratna Pharmaceuticals Laboratories wherein it was expressly cautioned against isolating individual parts of a composite mark, as such an approach disregards how consumers actually experience and recall trademarks. The Dominant Feature Test is not exclusive either, and it is based on the element which is most distinctive, memorable, and likely to influence consumer perception. 

Common words like “PRIDE” cannot be benchmarked unless secondary meaning is proven. The similarity in these meanings cannot be isolated, which includes trade dress protection too. The bench found that “BLENDERS PRIDE” and “LONDON PRIDE” are distinct and the word “PRIDE” does not have distinctiveness. Claims cannot be made on bottle shape or colour scheme since they are not independently enforceable. Also, since the products in questions prepare premium and ultra-premium whiskeys targeted at a discerning customer base, the consumers are likely to exercise greater care when making purchases. The shared use of the laudatory word ‘PRIDE’, in isolation, cannot form the basis for injunctive relief.

Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Article

Marriage Laws in India: Legal Rules, Ceremonies and Registration Explained

How Marriage is Defined Under Indian Law

Marriage is an important event in Indian society, not just personally but also legally. It gives rise to many legal rights and duties. In India, different religious communities follow their own personal laws for marriage. At the same time, the Constitution guarantees all adults the right to marry a person of their choice.

In this article, we will explain what makes a marriage legally valid in India, what ceremonies are required, how registration works, and what happens if the legal conditions are not followed.

The Legal Meaning of Marriage

Marriage is treated differently under different Indian laws. For example:

  • Hindu law treats marriage as a sacred, lifelong bond.
  • Muslim law considers marriage a civil contract.
  • Christian and Parsi laws follow a combination of religious and statutory procedures.
  • The Special Marriage Act, 1954 allows marriage without religious ceremonies, especially useful for interfaith couples.

Though different in form, all laws require some basic conditions to be fulfilled for a marriage to be valid.

Basic Conditions for a Valid Marriage

No matter which law applies, these are the most commonly required conditions:

  1. Age:
    • Under most laws, the minimum age is 21 for the groom and 18 for the bride.
  2. Mental capacity:
    • Both parties should be capable of giving free and full consent. They must not be suffering from serious mental disorders at the time of marriage.
  3. No existing marriage:
    • Most laws require that neither person should be already married unless the previous spouse has died or the earlier marriage is legally dissolved.
  4. Not closely related:
    • Under Hindu and Special Marriage laws, parties cannot be within the prohibited degrees of relationship unless custom allows. For Muslims, the rules depend on sect and school of thought.
  5. Free consent:
    • A marriage done through force, fraud or misunderstanding of identity can be declared voidable.
  6. Custom or ceremony:
    • The form of the ceremony depends on the personal law of the parties. For example, saptapadi is important in Hindu ceremonies, while Muslim marriages focus on offer, acceptance and witnesses.

Ceremonies under Different Laws

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955

A Hindu marriage must include a proper religious ceremony. There is no single fixed form, but the ceremony should be according to the customs of at least one party. Most commonly, the bride and groom take seven steps (saptapadi) around a sacred fire. If this is done, the marriage is legally complete.

The courts have held that even symbolic forms of this ceremony — such as walking around incense sticks — may be accepted if both parties intended to marry each other and followed the process publicly .

Muslim Law

Under Muslim law, marriage is known as Nikah and is a civil contract. The conditions are:

  • There must be a proposal (ijab) and acceptance (qubool) in the same sitting.
  • It must take place before two adult male witnesses or one male and two female witnesses.
  • Both parties must consent freely.
  • The husband agrees to pay mehr (a gift or payment) to the wife.

There is no religious ritual or priest required. However, customary practices like nikahnama (written contract) are often followed.

Christian Marriage Act, 1872

Christian marriages must be performed by a licensed minister or in the presence of a Marriage Registrar. The couple must declare that they accept each other as husband and wife. Two witnesses must be present. The ceremony must take place between 6 AM and 7 PM, unless special permission is given.

Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936

A valid Parsi marriage must be conducted by a Parsi priest in the presence of two Parsi witnesses. The Ashirvad ceremony, which includes prayers and blessings, is essential. Both parties must declare that they accept each other.

Special Marriage Act, 1954

This Act allows people from different religions or those who do not wish to marry under religious laws to marry. The process includes:

  • Giving notice to the Marriage Officer.
  • Waiting for 30 days (objection period).
  • Declaring the marriage in front of the officer and three witnesses.
  • Getting the marriage registered, which is mandatory.

No religious ceremony is required.

What if Legal Requirements Are Ignored?

If the required conditions are not followed, the marriage may be:

  • Void:
    • Automatically invalid. For example, bigamous marriages or those within prohibited relationships.
  • Voidable:
    • Valid unless challenged. Examples include marriages under duress, fraud or mental incapacity.
  • Irregular (in Muslim law):
    • Lacking certain formalities like witnesses, but can be corrected by fulfilling missing conditions.

Example: A Hindu man marrying a Christian woman through Hindu rituals, without the woman converting, may not result in a valid marriage unless the requirements of conversion or legal ceremony are fulfilled .

Is Marriage Registration Necessary?

Under the Hindu Marriage Act and Muslim law, registration is not compulsory but strongly advised. It acts as legal proof in case of divorce, inheritance, or maintenance claims.

The Supreme Court of India has urged all states to make registration mandatory for all marriages, regardless of religion, to ensure clarity and reduce fraud .

Under the Special Marriage Act, registration is mandatory, as it is part of the marriage process itself.

Are Live-In Relationships Recognised?

Live-in relationships are not considered marriages, but Indian courts have offered some protection:

  • If a couple lives together for a long time like husband and wife, their relationship may be recognised under laws like the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
  • However, socially, such relationships are still not widely accepted, especially in smaller towns and rural areas .

Conclusion

Understanding the legal rules of marriage helps individuals avoid future complications. Whether you’re getting married under religious law or a civil one, always check:

  • Whether you meet the age and mental capacity requirements
  • If the proper ceremonies or legal steps are followed
  • Whether registration is needed
  • That both parties consent freely

Marriage is not just a social union — it creates legal consequences that affect your entire life. Taking care to fulfil all legal conditions ensures that your marriage stands firm not just emotionally, but also under the law.


Join Our WhatsApp Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Join our Telegram Channel for Opportunity Updates

Get Daily Updates

Next Article

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

contact@lawdrishti.com

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

advertise@lawdrishti.com

Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)

See the below animation to allow notifications.

Start getting Lawdrishti updates useful for you!

Contact Us

For Submitting a Post

For Banner ads & admission campaigns

Contact us
For Submitting a Post
For Banner ads & admission campaigns
Timing

Hours: 9 AM – 9 PM (Mon-Sat)